When should you change marketing agency? Seven signs, and how to switch safely
Change agency when you cannot say what you received for last month’s fee, when reports show activity but not enquiries, or when the same problems return after you have raised them. Before you leave, have one direct conversation and set a 60-day target. If nothing changes, switch, and use the handover steps below to protect your accounts and your data.
Put the advice into practice
Turn scattered marketing into a considered plan
Connect strategy, creative, channels and ongoing review around your sales process.
Explore our marketing services
Discuss an ongoing marketing partnershipWhat are the signs it is not working?
1. You cannot say what you got last month
You should be able to name the work delivered without opening a report. If you can’t, the scope is unclear or the work is not being done.
2. Reports show activity, not outcomes
Posts published, impressions and clicks are easy to report. Qualified enquiries, proposals and sales are what you are paying for.
3. You are always the one chasing
If you start every conversation and remind them of deadlines, you are managing the agency as well as paying it.
4. The people have changed
The senior person who won your business has gone quiet, and the account is run by someone junior who is still learning it.
5. Nothing new has been suggested in six months
A good agency brings ideas and tells you what to stop. One that only does what it is told is a supplier, not a partner.
6. They do not understand your buyers
The content could be about any business in your industry. Nobody has asked to speak to your sales team.
7. The same issue keeps coming back
You have raised it twice. It improved for a fortnight, then returned.
One sign on its own is a conversation. Three or more is a pattern.
What should you try before leaving?
Switching costs time, so give the current agency one fair chance.
- Say it directly. Ask for a meeting with the most senior person. Describe the problem with examples.
- Agree one measurable goal for the next 60 days. For example, a set number of qualified enquiries, or a specific piece of work delivered.
- Ask for the plan in writing. Who will do what, by when.
- Review at 60 days. If it has been met, stay. If not, give notice.
Also check your own side. Agencies often underperform because approvals are slow, the brief keeps changing or enquiries are not followed up. A new agency will hit the same wall.
What should you check before giving notice?
Read your contract for three things.
- Notice period: often one to three months. Check the date it counts from.
- Minimum term: you may owe fees to the end of it.
- Ownership: who owns the advertising accounts, analytics, website, content and creative files.
For what a replacement is likely to cost, see our marketing retainer price guide.
How do you switch without losing momentum?
Step 1: Secure your accounts first
Before you say anything, confirm that someone in your business has owner or administrator access to:
- Google Ads and Google Analytics
- Google Search Console and Google Business Profile
- Meta and LinkedIn advertising accounts
- Your website, domain name and hosting
- Your email marketing platform and CRM
If the agency owns any of these, ask for ownership to be transferred. Do this calmly and early. Our advertising account ownership checklist covers what to look for.
Step 2: Collect your files
Ask for brand files, creative source files, content, reports, audience lists and a list of everything currently running.
Step 3: Choose the new agency before notice ends
Aim for a two to four week overlap so campaigns are not left unattended. Our guide on how to choose a marketing agency covers what to ask.
Step 4: Give notice in writing
Keep it short and factual. State the end date and the handover you expect.
Step 5: Arrange a handover call
One call between the two agencies, with you present, covering what is running, what is planned and what was learned.
Step 6: Remove access on the final day
Remove the old agency’s logins once the handover is complete.
What should the first 90 days with a new agency look like?
| Period | What should happen |
|---|---|
| Days 1 to 30 | Access checks, a review of what exists, a baseline of current results and an agreed list of priorities |
| Days 31 to 60 | The first work delivered against those priorities, and the first monthly report |
| Days 61 to 90 | A review of early results and an adjusted plan for the next quarter |
If you reach day 60 with no plan and no delivered work, raise it straight away.
Next step
If you are weighing a change, get in touch to arrange a short call. We will ask about your current setup and tell you plainly whether we think a switch is worth it. You can also see how our retainer packages work.
